Equities Are Junior in The Capital Structure- Bonds Lead Stocks
“I and others were mistaken early on in saying that the subprime crisis would be contained. The causal relationship between the housing problem and the broad financial system was very complex and difficult to predict.”— Ben Bernanke
“Bonds lead stocks. That’s key because we think stocks follow bonds, or bonds lead stocks.” – Tom Lee
Many intelligent people were initially dismissive of deteriorating conditions in the mortgage market. Housing had always been a sturdy source of demand in the U.S., and there was nothing in the historical data driving many models to suggest what happened was even possible. Few people understood just how catastrophic relatively new types of asset-backed securities and derivatives could be to a company’s balance sheet, until they saw the devastation for themselves.
Daily Technical Strategy covering all major trends!
Video and Research Publications!
The complex interplays between housing prices, the availability and types of mortgages and the exponential rise in strategic defaults as foreclosures rose was difficult to forecast or anticipate. A few well-laureled folks did anticipate it and made off handsomely, but there’s already a movie about that.
While the people who bet against the mortgage market received the publicity, the problem was that virtually all of the banking industry had bet in the other direction. It also didn’t help that sometimes derivatives positions that proved very problematic were used to reduce regulatory capital when they increased risk. Rating agencies failed in their core function.
The shocking events that transpired toward the end of the first decade of the new millennium resulted in the greatest financial collapse since the Great Depression. The global economy was threatened since one of the major sources of demand that was at the root of the problem was from a savings glut held by foreign investors searching for yield[MG1]. Investors, and models largely operated on the assumption that mortgage securities were as safe as U.S. government debt, which was clearly not true. One of the lessons crystallized by the extraordinary events was that if problems occur up the chain in the capital structure from equity, even seemingly invincible companies can be smashed to dust.
However, even in 2009, the speed of the decline was symmetric to the speed of the recovery as our graphic above showed. Even the turmoil around COVID was less of a drop than what happened following the collapse of Lehman Brothers. Markets got cut in half and there was great reason to fear far worse outcomes than ended up transpiring. It likely would have been a lot worse if it weren’t for government assistance directly to distressed and undercapitalized banks.
What is the bane of all shareholders? Bankruptcy, of course. Owning equity in a company is junior in the capital structure because it has the lowest repayment priority in the event of insolvency. If you own a company’s bonds, then you have a higher likelihood of getting paid back in the event of bankruptcy than if you own their equity.
So, when the entire banking system loaded up on illiquid asset-backed securities and derivatives backed by very shaky mortgage assets and you have bankruptcies on the scale of Lehman Brothers and hundreds of bank failures, the outlook was bad for shareholders. Believe it or not, forced liquidation no matter what the cause is often worse on prices than wars, famines and even pandemics.
Interested in investing with ETFs?
FSI Sector Allocation
Our FSI Sector Allocation has outperformed the S&P 500 by 3.84% since inception!
When times are good and prospects for growth are improving you are happy owning a company’s equity. However, if a company is having trouble paying back its debts in any fashion, then it is decidedly a very bad thing for the equity shareholders. If there isn’t enough for the company’s creditors, then there definitely isn’t enough for those who own the equity and most often a company will not make it out of this situation without the protection afforded by bankruptcy to restructure.
Series of 3~11 minutesLast updated3 months ago
Understanding Risk and Return: Hallmarks of Investing
Risk/return is so crucial to investing that it is sometimes considered the essential element of the whole craft. In this guide, we provide insights and tools to better understand risk and how to control it.
Series of 3~15 minutesLast updated3 months ago
Investor Psychology 100
You may have heard this before: Many of the world’s top investors manage their portfolios well because they manage their emotions well. But what does that look like? If you want to know more about investor psychology – arguably the most critical component of the entire game -- you’ve come to the right place. Let’s dive in.
Series of 8~22 minutesLast updated3 months ago
Financial Instruments! How to use them and what are they for!
In this guide, we will talk about financial instruments. We will cover stocks, bonds, various kinds of derivatives, and more!
Series of 1~6 minutesLast updated3 months ago
What is Ethereum?
We are launching a new guide covering Ethereum, the highlights from inception to the current state of the network!
Series of 1~17 minutesLast updated4 months ago
Earnings Season and Financial Earnings Reports Explained
In this guide, Brian Rauscher will explain how to read and digest all the information packed in our earnings reports.