Our Search for Critical Minerals Might Be About to Shift

“Every strike brings me closer to a home run.” — Babe Ruth

Chart of the Day

Our Search for Critical Minerals Might Be About to Shift

Good morning!

China’s current chokehold on the production of critical materials like lithium and rare-earth minerals has caused plenty of consternation in U.S. and European corridors of power this year. China’s leverage wasn’t exactly a secret before this, but this was the first time China actually used it on a broad scale.

The U.S. responded by acquiring stakes in rare-earth producer MP Materials (MP 2.91% ) and lithium projects like Thacker Pass, while Europe formulated plans to stockpile critical minerals and introduced the Critical Raw Materials Act to boost domestic extraction and processing. A variety of deals and partnerships between the U.S., Europe, and their allies, has arisen to strengthen the supply chain. Yet there’s a growing awareness that those plans might not be quite as necessary as we feared — not that we’re out of the proverbial woods just yet. 

Apparently, part of the answer might be coal. 

No, we’re not talking about “clean coal.” Instead, we’re talking about coal that’s already been burnt. Some estimate that the U.S. has produced as much as 81 billion tons of coal ash over the decades, with millions of tons still produced every year. Research from the University of Texas at Austin strongly suggests the possibility that we could extract enough rare-earth elements from the waste product to satisfy as much as 94% of our current annual demand. The geologists estimate that a total of about 1,873 million tons of previously produced coal ash could still be recoverable, yielding up to $8.4 billion (11 million tons) worth of rare earth elements, including neodymium, dysprosium, yttrium, europium, and terbium.

Meanwhile, a growing body of evidence suggests that about 20 to 40 million metric tons of lithium might be sitting in a (dormant) supervolcano sitting on the Nevada-Oregon border. If these estimates prove even somewhat accurate, the so-called McDermitt Caldera would be the largest deposit yet discovered. Dr. Thomas R. Benson, a geologist at Lithium Americas Corporation (LAC 7.41% ), led the research into the potential deposit located in the aforementioned Thacker Pass.

To be clear, neither development represents an instant panacea to the challenges facing the U.S. and its allies. The pilot plant developing rare-earth extraction, newly built at the Wyoming Innovation Center, just began work in the spring, and it remains unclear whether the current proposed extraction process can be sufficiently scaled up in an economically viable manner. Meanwhile, the process of mining and refining lithium deposits remains infamously complex and time-consuming. Nevertheless, one simply never knows when an existing paradigm will be disrupted.

Share your thoughts

Are fears of Chinese dominance in the production and refinement of critical materials overblown? Click here to send us your response.

📧✍️Here’s what a reader commented📧✍️

Q:  Are you planning to keep holding your Nvidia after last week?

A: Surely AI is prominent.  But recalling the deadwood of dotcom and reflecting on 25 years of progress as the titans emerged, I believe we are indeed in an epoch the likes of which are unparalleled.  The key aspect Tom has pointed to is tech development amid a demographic shift.  We have less to worry about our finances than the delicate planet we inhabit.  To be sure the gamification of everything will create a point when you better grab a chair.   You will know when the time comes. The hints will be unmistakable. Enjoy the ride.

Catch up with FS Insight

Equity markets continued to climb higher, after the grinding selloff since the Oct highs. In our view, the rally into YE remains intact.

Technical

Overall, given that a December FOMC rate cut is still uncertain, I still feel that a choppy market for now makes more sense for FOMC vs. a straight shot back to new highs given the bearish weekly momentum in US Indices.

Crypto

BTC reclaimed $87K and the Coinbase/Binance spread moved back into premium territory prior to US market close (a good sign).

News We’re Following

Breaking News

  • Nvidia takes $2 billion stake in Synopsys with expanded computing power partnership CNBC 

Markets and economy

  • Trump says he has made his choice to lead the Federal Reserve BBG
  • Rapid growth of US tax-minimising ETFs draws scrutiny FT 
  • Trump says he has made his choice to lead the Federal Reserve BBG

Business

  • Amazon and Google launch multicloud service for faster connectivity REU
  • Credit Suisse hit with laundering charges in Mozambique case BBG
  • HSBC signs deal to use Mistral’s AI tools FT 

Politics

  • Congress opens inquiries after report that U.S. targeted boat-strike survivors WSJ 
  • Congress waits on Trump as December health sprint begins POL

Overseas

  • Indonesia floods death toll passes 500 BBC
  • Yen rises as BOJ hints at rate hike; dollar braces for crucial December REU
  • China tells stats providers to halt home sales data publication BBG

Of Interest 

  • Tom Stoppard, playwright, 1937-2025 FT
Overnight
S&P Futures
-37 point(s) (-0.54% )
overnight range:
-58 to +5 point(s)
APAC
Nikkei
-1.89%
Topix
-1.19%
China SHCOMP
+0.65%
Hang Seng
+0.67%
Korea
-0.16%
Singapore
+0.05%
Australia
-0.57%
India
-0.10%
Taiwan
-1.03%
Europe
Stoxx
50 -0.36%
Stoxx
600 -0.37%
FTSE
100 +0.03%
DAX
-1.02%
CAC
40 -0.40%
Italy
-0.80%
IBEX
-0.26%
Canada
+0.60%
Mexico
+1.44%
Brazil
+0.45%
FX
Dollar Index (DXY)
-0.19% to 99.268
EUR/USD
+0.21% to 1.1622
GBP/USD
-0.08% to 1.3224
USD/JPY
+0.61% to 155.24
USD/CNY
+0.04% to 7.0718
USD/CNH
+0.03% to 7.0684
USD/CHF
+0.10% to 0.8032
USD/CAD
-0.06% to 1.3986
AUD/USD
-0.06% to 0.6546
UST Term Structure
2Y-3M Spread narrowed
-0.6bps to -32.5bps
10Y-2Y Spread widened
2.3bps to 54.3bps
30Y-10Y Spread widened
1.2bps to 65.8bps
Yesterday's Recap
SPX
+0.54%
SPX Eq Wt
+0.54%
NASDAQ
100 +0.78%
NASDAQ Comp
+0.65%
Russell Midcap
+0.58%
R2k
+0.58%
R1k Value
+0.67%
R1k Growth
+0.45%
R2k Value
+0.36%
R2k Growth
+0.78%
FANG+
+0.88%
Semis
+1.31%
Software
+1.09%
Biotech
+0.25%
Regional Banks
-0.28%
SPX GICS1 Sorted
-0.50%
REITs
+0.40%
Materials
+0.51%
Tech
+0.52%
SPX
+0.54%
Cons Staples
+0.56%
Indu
+0.57%
Fin
+0.71%
Utes
+0.72%
Comm Srvcs
+0.73%
Cons Disc
+0.90%
Energy
+1.32%
USD HY OaS
All Sectors
-2.6bps to 344bps
All Sectors ex-Energy
-4.4bps 328bps
Cons Disc
-2.0bps to 491bps
Indu
-1.7bps to 255bps
Tech
-7.1bps to 325bps
Comm Srvcs
-5.1bps to 286bps
Materials
-2.1bps to 263bps
Energy
-1.4bps to 335bps
Fin Snr
-4.7bps to 243bps
Fin Sub
-3.5bps to 382bps
Cons Staples
-10.6bps to 428bps
Healthcare
-4.2bps to 348bps
Utes -4.4bps to 241bps *
DateTimeDescriptionEstimateLast
12/19:45 AMNov F Oct S&P Manu PMI51.951.9
12/38:30 AMSep Import Price m/m00.3
12/39:45 AMNov F Sep F S&P Srvcs PMI5555
12/310:00 AMNov Sep ISM Srvcs PMI5252.4
12/510:00 AMDec P Oct P UMich 1yr Inf Expn/a4.5
12/510:00 AMDec P Oct P UMich Sentiment5251
12/510:00 AMSep PCE m/m0.30.3
12/510:00 AMSep Core PCE m/m0.20.23
12/510:00 AMSep PCE y/y2.82.7
12/510:00 AMSep Core PCE y/y2.82152.90511
Disclosures (show)

Get invaluable analysis of the market and stocks. Cancel at any time. Start Free Trial

Articles Read 2/2

🎁 Unlock 1 extra article by joining our Community!

You’ve reached your limit of 2 free monthly articles. Please enter your email to unlock 1 more articles.

Already have an account? Sign In

Events

Trending tickers in our research

Get invaluable analysis of the market and stocks. Cancel at any time. Start Free Trial

Articles Read 2/2

🎁 Unlock 1 extra article by joining our Community!

You’ve reached your limit of 2 free monthly articles. Please enter your email to unlock 1 more articles.

Already have an account? Sign In