Our Views

The public remains rattled by the rapid collapse of SVB Financial (aka Silicon Valley Bank). SVB has exposed the operational challenges (deposits vs investments) for banks in a world where central banks have raised rates sharply. And equity and bondholders are wary given that FDIC/Fed actions wiped out stakeholders. Worsening this, several rating agencies have downgraded regional banks, moving many to below investment grade and thus raising these banks’ cost of funding.

While the collapse of SVB has triggered logical concerns of contagion, too many investors are reflexively overlaying 2008 GFC. It is the most recent financial crisis and the freshest for many. Perhaps the liquidity actions taken by Credit Suisse will calm markets, but if not, we expect communication from the Fed. Much of the problems for the banks stem from the aggressive Fed hikes which are hammering the banking industry’s securities portfolios while deposits are drained from dwindling savings, the move to USTs, and distrust of banks.

The Fed hiking aggressively further is delivering even greater pain to the banks. Fed hikes are directly driving losses for banks which was $620b at end of 2022, and the Powell testimony last week likely pushed this to nearly $900b (as 2Y and 10Y yields surged). In other words, the Fed’s monetary policy is finally “biting” (they looked for lags) and thus, the Fed can take its foot off the gas.

For the equity markets, there are signs of lingering carnage from the SIVB collapse, and these “smoking ruins” are why we believe the Fed will move cautiously into the March FOMC meeting next week. While not “explicit” in its dual mandate, the Federal Reserve Act established the Fed to “provide the nation with a safer, more flexible and more stable monetary and financial system” (thanks MH of SF for this). Bond volatility (ICE MOVE index) has surged to its highest level since 2009 and is amplifying stresses across credit and rates markets.

Our Head of Technical Strategy, Mark Newton, believes equity markets are bottoming near-term. but the next five days are critical to whether this view holds.

  • In this timeframe, we get more Feb inflation/economic data and March FOMC rate decisions.
  • As inflation surged in 2021-2022, investors were quick to label inflation as an era with risk of inflation being sticky for years. But that analog has not held. Even looking at lagged CPI data, inflation has softened in February compared to January evidenced by the Feb jobs report, Feb CPI and PPI. So the trend remains inflation is softening.
  • The SVB collapse and the associated ripple effects across the start-up community should deliver a softening of the labor market. Moreover, with financial stability more at the top of mind for many, how many employees will now seek raises? Similarly, the credit shock and higher cost of borrowing means credit growth on the margin will slow.

These are reasons we expect inflation to fall in future months and is also evidenced by Fed rate expectations and the plunge in rates. The question is, have rates fallen due to “inflation breaking” or because “economy breaking.” reasons noted above, we think this is more “inflation breaking” and thus, Fed can take its foot off the gas. Moreover, the relative resilience of stocks (relatively milder drawdown and the lower amplitude rise in VIX) also suggest to us this drop is inflation.

Read the Latest First Word
  • SPX and QQQ likely bottomed this past Monday; Friday’s pullback looks buyable
  • Gold’s breakout to new 11-month highs should continue to drive Metals outperformance
  • Utilities sector looks to be peaking after strong six-week outperformance
Read the Latest Technical Strategy
  • There has been a lot of discussion, news, speculation, and debate surrounding the recent bank chaos. The overall equity markets have remained range-bound as investors process new areas of concern, such as Credit Suisse, and the responses from governments and central banks. Based on my interactions with clients, we are concluding the week with a fair degree of apprehension, but there do not appear to be any signs of panic.
  • Next week, we will hear from the Fed and Chair Powell. The Street is eager to learn how they are considering recent events and whether it will affect their ongoing fight against inflation. It would not be surprising if the Fed suggests that the recent bank issues need to be closely monitored, and flexibility will be necessary to see how things develop. I have been in the “higher for longer” camp and see little reason to change my stance since I place a low probability that the Fed will abandon their ongoing fight against inflation.
  • In terms of positioning, my work continues to indicate that a barbell approach of traditional defense and secular offensive growth, with a preference for high-quality and larger-cap stocks, is still appropriate. As a reminder, I upgraded the Technology sector in February, and my key indicators are still relatively favorable for the next 6-12 months, despite the sector being overbought in the short term.
  • My primary points are still pertinent and reinforce my long-standing bearish view of the equity market. I still advise caution, maintaining a higher cash position than usual, utilizing rallies as opportunities to sell, reposition, increase hedges, and initiate new short positions. My research suggests that significant risks remain, and equities may still experience downside, with the October lows being a potential target, at the very least.
Read the Latest Wall Street Whispers
  • The Federal Reserve’s recent move to inject liquidity into the banking industry effectively neutralizes the impact of quantitative tightening (QT) thus far. Although some may argue that this lending program lacks the stimulus power of quantitative easing (QE), it still results in the creation of new dollars, which will enhance liquidity as banks borrow from the Fed and depositors channel their funds into securities or other banks, triggering a corresponding demand for securities to cover the new deposits.
  • The PBOC has lowered the reserve requirement ratio (RRR) by 25 basis points for all banks, except those with a 5% reserve ratio, to maintain ample liquidity and support China’s economic recovery. This move is intended to boost credit growth, lower funding costs, and encourage lending by banks, which will increase global liquidity conditions. The BTC price rose along with the Shanghai Composite Index after this announcement.
  • The strengthening correlation between BTC and gold, coupled with the ongoing banking crisis, suggests that some investors may be turning to Bitcoin as an alternative investment. The current 30-day correlation between Bitcoin and gold is higher than the correlation between Bitcoin and the Nasdaq 100

Core Strategy – Despite ongoing banking concerns, the risk asymmetry in 1H remains to the upside, as liquidity conditions for risk assets should remain favorable, buoyed by global liquidity increasing. Investors are increasingly turning to BTC and gold as alternative ways to store wealth during periods of inflation or increased risk, with BTC’s rising dominance potentially leading to sustained altcoin rallies down the road.

Read the Latest Crypto Strategy
  • The recent bank failures will heighten attention on the upcoming meeting of the Federal Open Markets Committee.
  • Chair Powell’s traditional post-FOMC press conference will also provide an opportunity for him to address the condition of the U.S. banking system.
  • Tough questions are expected in coming weeks from members of the House Financial Services Committee and the Senate Banking Committee.
Read the Latest US Policy

Wall Street Debrief — Weekly Roundup

Key Takeaways

  • The S&P 500 advanced 1.43% this week to close at 3,916.64, and the Nasdaq gained 4.41% as investors bet on technology ahead of next week’s Federal Reserve policy meeting. Bitcoin had a monster week, rising more than 25% amid chaos in the traditional banking system.
  • Investors are assessing a complicated mix of signals about inflation and bank failures.
  • While the S&P 500 rose this week, oil prices and bond yields fell, which shows investors are worried about the economy.

“LUKE, WE'RE GONNA HAVE COMPANY!" Han Solo

Good evening:

Turmoil in the banking sector has left many investors with flashbacks to 2008’s GFC and even the 1980s savings and loan crisis, though some–including our Head of Research, Tom Lee–attribute this to reflexive human nature rather than any significant similarities to those historic events. Nevertheless, fallout from last week’s rapid collapse of Silicon Valley Bank SIVB spread throughout global markets this week, with Credit Suisse’s separate issues (problematic accounting among them) adding to the uncertainty. 

Politically, SIVB has generated a bipartisan perspective in Congress–aimed at the Fed. Lawmakers from both parties are questioning why the Fed failed to see trouble at the failed bank earlier or act to prevent it, with some noting that until March 10, SIVB CEO Greg Becker sat on the board of the San Francisco Fed. Still, our Washington Policy Strategist, Tom Block, said that while Congress will certainly respond to recent banking news, the debt-ceiling debate remains top-of-mind in Washington, D.C.

But at our office, the banking sector was a ubiquitous topic of discussion this week. In his webinar on Thursday, Tom Lee said that his 2023 outlook remained positive and unchanged. However, he acknowledged that in the unlikely event that the current turmoil is not contained, it has the potential to alter his outlook for the rest of the year. Lee said the next five trading days (i.e. until March 23) are critical, as markets see how the banking crisis unfolds, get more February inflation/economic data, and take in the March FOMC rate decision. 

During our research huddle following the webinar, Brian Rauscher, Head of Global Portfolio Strategy and Asset Allocation, agreed with Lee’s assessment of the banking crisis: “At the moment, it appears that direct contagion is not happening. I am not expecting a domino effect leading to a financial crisis,” he said.

But Rauscher warned, “We are not totally out of the woods yet. The smart money is still digesting the rescue of First Republic. There are likely a lot of idiosyncratic issues out there that have not shown their ugly heads yet, and a lot of banks have the same deposit-flight problem that hit SVB and SBNY. Other dead bodies will likely float to the surface in the months to come.” Asked whether there was any opportunity to be found in the sector, he described the situation as “tricky.” He explained, “Right now we’re in this random phase where a dead body could show up at any moment, and that could take the entire group down.”

Mark Newton is slightly more sanguine about the banking sector, though not confident. “From a technical perspective, a lot of banks have gotten down to levels low enough to at least consider a trade. U.S. banks are far better capitalized and better structured than European banks,” our Head of Technical Strategy noted. “There are many banks that have great liquidity that have been unfairly punished,” Newton said, pointing out that SIVB was an unusual case: “They didn’t have a risk officer for eight months and they clearly didn’t take any steps to hedge any of their holdings.”

Here’s a look at the Fear & Greed Index, which shows that fear hasn’t been this high since near last fall’s market lows:

Source: CNN

Regarding the broader market, Newton observed that although the indices held up this week, “the broader market has actually seen a lot of technical damage. If you look at Energy, Financials, Materials, and Industrials, they've all obviously been very very hard hit. It is going to be important to recoup that and start to have a very strong rally off these lows.”

That could happen, he noted. “I’ve argued that the back half of March is normally much, much better for markets. They typically bottom on the 10th trading day of the month, which is this week.” 

Newton credited large-cap technology for supporting the S&P 500 and Nasdaq benchmarks this week. “Tech is 27% of the market. Apple is 7% of the S&P. You’re seeing a lot of good movement in technology.”

Lee observed: “Tech is close to erasing all of the underperformance in 2022. If you thought tech was terrible in 2022 and you just held on, you’re almost back to where we started.” From a broader market perspective and beyond the short term, Lee remains optimistic, citing the market’s resilience this month even in the face of the bank crisis and Fed Chair Jay Powell’s hawkish testimony earlier in March, with the SPX flat for the month. 

“The trend remains: Inflation is softening,” Lee concluded.

Elsewhere

French President Emmanuel Macron used a constitutional provision to force his pension-reform bill through the lower house of Parliament, where it faced a long-shot struggle. The bill, which raises the retirement age from 62 to 64 to reduce the massive liabilities of France’s generous retirement benefits system, was hugely unpopular nationwide. As intense protests–some violent–flared up across the country, multiple political parties have filed a motion for a no-confidence vote in Macron’s government. A successful no-confidence vote, likely next week, is the only way to stop the bill from becoming law. 

China’s January-February economic data showed accelerating growth post-lockdown, with industrial production up 2.4% compared to December’s 1.3%. Retail sales were up 3.5% compared to -1.8% in December. Unemployment overall came in at 5.6%, but youth unemployment (16-24 years old) remained high, rising to 18.1% over 16.7% in December. (The country releases January and February data together to avoid misleading distortions due to the Chinese New Year holiday.)

The European Central Bank raised interest rates by 50 bps to 3%, judging that the EU banking sector was sufficiently “resilient” to withstand the central bank’s efforts to lower inflation. It was the ECB’s sixth consecutive rate hike since July 2022.

Argentina’s YoY inflation rose above 100%, climbing to 102.5% in February. It was the first time inflation had breached the 100% mark since 1991.

The UK Office for National Statistics updated the basket of products and services used to calculate inflation. Going forward, the prices of digital cameras and non top-40 compact discs (CDs) will no longer impact inflation in Britain, while the prices of items like soundbars, video doorbells, and e-bikes will be used in the calculations.

And finally: Road fatalities in the U.S. are up 22% since 2019, and experts attribute much of that increase to distracted driving due to smartphone use. Please stay safe. 

By the way, we’d like your feedback. How are you enjoying this weekly roundup? We read everything our members send and make every effort to write back. Please email thoughts and suggestions to inquiry@fsinsight.com

Important Events

March FOMC rate decision
Wed, Mar 22 2:00 PM ET

Est.: 4.75%-5.00% Prev.: 4.50%-4.75%

The FOMC’s decision on the Fed Funds rate.

New Home Sales February
Thu, Mar 23 10:00 AM ET

Est.: 650K Prev.: 670K

Measures the sales of new single-family homes in the United States.

S&P Global US Manufacturing PMI March P
Fri, Mar 24 9:45 AM ET

Est.: 47.0 Prev.: 47.3

Measures the performance of the manufacturing sector, as calculated from a survey of purchasing managers at 600 industrial companies.

Stock List Performance

Strategy YTD YTD vs S&P 500 Inception vs S&P 500
Granny Shots
+4.62%
+0.48%
+98.84%
View
Sector Allocation
+11.75%
-4.16%
+0.90%
View
Brian’s Dunks
Performance available here.
Disclosures (show)

Stay up to date with the latest articles and business updates. Subscribe to our newsletter

Articles Read 1/2

🎁 Unlock 1 extra article by joining our Community!

Stay up to date with the latest articles. You’ll even get special recommendations weekly.

Already have an account? Sign In

Want to receive Regular Market Updates to your Inbox?

I am your default error :)