Hawkish Market Response to FOMC, But We See Overreaction

Our Views

Tom Lee, CFA
Tom Lee, CFA
AC
Head of Research

Since the FOMC rate decision (2 trading days), the S&P 500 is down about 2.5% and down about 4% for the month. The markets viewed the September FOMC rate decision (and summary economic projections, or SEP) hawkishly. Stocks have been under pressure the entire month as US 10-yr yields relentlessly marched higher from 4.0% to nearly 4.5%. Unfortunately, our expectation for equities to gain post-FOMC did not materialize.

We view the magnitude of the equity decline and commensurate surge in yields as disproportionate to the FOMC rate decision and press conference. Yields on the US treasuries surged to multi-decade highs yesterday – the fixed income market reacted strongly to the FOMC.

However, after re-listening and re-reading the transcript, the “higher for longer” message is not as hawkish, given that the rise in Fed funds by YE 2024 stems from higher growth. It would be less logical for the Fed to not think Fed funds needs to adjust in response to the GDP forecast going up. Our take is the “higher for longer DUE to higher GDP” has a more dovish tone. A hawkish take would be if inflation persistence went up and therefore Fed funds needs to stay high. But the SEP does not have a rise in inflation.

We also need to be mindful that the Fed’s SEP is merely a best guess of the future. And their prior forecasts have seen substantial error relative to what actually happened. The only 3 CPI service categories with high inflation are:

  • Housing (set to fall)
  • Transportations services (set to fall)
  • “Other” — an motley category, hence, called “other”
Read the Latest First Word
Mark L. Newton, CMT
Mark L. Newton, CMT
AC
Head of Technical Strategy
  • QQQ and SPX technically should bottom initially at August lows,but meaningful rallies might prove difficult until rates peak.
  • 5, 10, and 30-year Yields breakout to highest levels since 2007.
  • QQQ holding up much better than SPY gives optimism towards buying dips in early Oct.
Read the Latest Daily Technical Strategy
Sean Farrell
Sean Farrell
AC
Head of Crypto Strategy
  • Fed Chair Powell’s decision to keep interest rates unchanged while unveiling a hawkish-leaning dot plot led to negative market reactions, pushing the U.S. 10-Year Treasury yield to 4.5% and creating headwinds for crypto, even as the Fed’s own projections suggest a softer economic landing.
  • This week’s emerging trend of cryptoassets outperforming during APAC trading hours and weakening during U.S. hours contrasts with earlier underperformance in the APAC session, spurring theories from Chinese economic stimulus to capital flight, and coincides with increased altcoin activity.
  • The recent Eclipse mainnet announcement, leveraging both Solana and Ethereum, is likely to expand developer options and enhance both ecosystems, countering skeptics who fear it may undermine Solana.
  • Core Strategy – Despite initial hopes of overcoming the typically negative September seasonality in the crypto market, this year seems to be following the trend, with a continued rise in rates and DXY strength, leading us to recommend reduced exposure to altcoins and more cautious risk management in the coming weeks.
Read the Latest Crypto Strategy
L . Thomas Block
L . Thomas Block
Washington Policy Strategist
  • Chaos amongst House Republicans prevents progress on efforts to avoid October 1 government shutdown.
  • Even the normally straightforward issue of funding the Department of Defense got bogged down on two separate occasions this week.
  • The Senate is now also attempting to craft a bipartisan measure on a 60-day Continuing Resolution to fund the federal government past October 1.
Read the Latest US Policy

Wall Street Debrief — Weekly Roundup

Key Takeaways

  • The S&P 500 declined 2.9% this week to close 4,320.06, while the Nasdaq slid 3.7% to 13,211.81. Bitcoin was flat, around 26,535.
  • The FOMC’s projections provoked a hawkish market response, sinking equities while sending yields surging.
  • We see this as an overreaction, and we remain constructive for the rest of the year.

“If everything you try works, you aren’t trying hard enough.”  ~ Gordon Moore

Good evening:

As the week opened, Head of Technical Strategy Mark Newton pointed out that in the past, this week has been one of the worst of the year in a historical/seasonal sense. This trend continued this week, with stocks sliding slightly on Monday and Tuesday, then falling sharply after the FOMC meeting and subsequent press conference. 

“We’ve seen a pretty sharp sell-off in both equities and the bond market,” our Head of Research Tom Lee acknowledged, “and that’s naturally led to a lot of angst.”

With the target range for Fed funds remaining unchanged this month, it’s clear that the markets had a hawkish reaction to the FOMC’s dot plot and Summary of Economic Projections (SEP). We saw a shift in the committee’s median expectations of YE 2023 and YE 2024 rates, as well as improved projections of GDP, inflation, and labor markets. Many market participants viewed the higher expectations for YE 2024 rates as a shift toward a “higher for longer” stance. Yields surged to multi-decade highs and equities sank in response.

But Lee viewed this as an overreaction, and suggested that the market would eventually come to see it as such and moderate accordingly. “The Fed raised its expectations of rates in 2024 not because inflation’s up – Powell made that clear several times,” he noted. “This was a response to a 40 bp increase in GDP estimates.”

He also pointed out that despite the shift in median expectations for hikes to the end of 2023, “they’ve actually removed some hawkish views between June and September.” In June, one FOMC member anticipated three more hikes before the year ended, and two anticipated two more hikes. Those three members have clearly gotten less hawkish in terms of rate-hike expectations. We illustrate that with our Chart of the Week:

Mark Newton, our Head of Technical Strategy, noted that despite Lee’s assessment, “we saw rates across the board scream up to the highest level since 2007. Historically, in recent months, we've seen a pretty good negative correlation between rates and equities, so with rates being up at the highest level of 16 years, we're seeing equities respond directly to this spike up in interest rates.”

Purely from a technical perspective, Newton sees no immediate change in rates: “When I look at a chart of the 10-year on a daily basis, what I see is that we're getting closer to what's going to be a pretty prominent peak in rates,” he said at our weekly huddle. “My own cycles suggest that rates are going to retreat, likely starting in late October, November, and down through next fall. I think we're going to have a pretty big pullback and that should provide some tailwind for the US economy at a time when it’s needed – and it might be refreshing for those that want to buy houses,” he added.

“In general, I expect rates are going to be lower into next year. I don't think that the 10-year is going to get above 5%. So we're approaching a pretty good risk-reward for those that want to buy Treasuries, I think.”

Lee did not voice an opinion about the yields in the near or intermediate term, but he did point out that although many equity investors view higher yields with trepidation due to what they might do to P/E, these fears are not entirely justified. “Since 1930, a 4.5% US 10-year yield has not necessarily been a P/E killer,” he observed. “In fact, the ‘sweet spot’ for P/E is 3.5% to 5.5% yields which have seen an average P/E of ~20X. US yields below 3.5% are actually associated with lower P/E.”

A note on Energy

“We've seen a little bit of evidence of crude getting extended and starting to roll over,” Newton said. “I think crude is close to short-term peaking out, and that means that Energy likely is not going to be the best group over the next three to six months. But really any pullback in Energy would be something I would buy into. Next year should be the time when crude gets up above 100. And I do think that is going to happen.”


Elsewhere 

The Bank of England paused its rate hikes for the first time since December 2021, opting to leave them at 5.25%. Commenting on the decision, BoE Governor Andrew Bailey acknowledged that “inflation has fallen a lot in recent months, and we think it will continue to do so.” Meanwhile, Sweden’s Risbank and Turkiye’s central bank both hiked rates this week to combat high inflation, to 4% and 30% respectively.

Amazon announced that it planned to hire 250,000 seasonal workers to help manage the winter holiday surge in orders, an increase over the 150,000 figure it hired during the 2022 holiday season. The company also announced slight hourly wage increases for seasonal, part-time, and full-time employees in its warehouse and delivery units.

Toyota announced a breakthrough in AI-powered robotics, with robots that can learn new “dextrous skills” purely through observation and demonstration, rather than coding. The Toyota Research Institute said its robots can now learn by using telemetry and robot vision to observe a human demonstration, then applying generative AI to acquire new skills such as using tools, pouring liquids, and even preparing simple breakfasts. (For example, robots learned to spread Nutella on bread, use an egg-beater, and flip pancakes.) Toyota’s new technology was facilitated by also giving the robots a sense of touch, so they need not rely solely on visual data.

Chevron has reached an agreement with workers at its Australian liquified natural gas facilities, concluding talks that began on September 8. The facilities account for 5% of global LNG production. 

Japan’s population continues to age, with the over-80 demographic now making up more than 10% of the population for the first time. In addition, 29.1% of Japan’s population is 65 or older. (For reference, in the US about 16.8% of the population is 65 or older.)

And finally: A Copenhagen court has ordered artist Jens Haaning to repay the Kunsten Museum of Modern Art for the DKK 532,549 (USD $76,400) in currency it lent to him after he delivered two blank canvases he titled “Take the Money and Run” instead of the two pieces the museum had commissioned. The museum had been under the impression that Haaning would use the cash to create artistic commentary about wage disparities within the European Union. Haaning told reporters that he no longer has the money. 


By the way, we’d like your feedback. How are you enjoying this weekly roundup? We read everything our members send and make every effort to write back. Please email thoughts and suggestions to inquiry@fsinsight.com.

Important Events

Conference Board Consumer Confidence September
Tue, Sep 26 10:00 AM ET

Est.: 105.5 Prev.: 106.1

A measure of Americans’ optimism about the future state of the economy and their own personal financial situations.

GDP National Economic Accounts -- Revisions
Thu, Sep 28 8:30 AM ET

Gross Domestic Product (Third Estimate) and Corporate Profits (Revised), 2nd Quarter 2023 and Comprehensive Update

PCE Core Deflator MoM August
Fri, Sep 29 8:30 AM ET

Est. 0.2% Prev.: 0.2%

The Fed’s preferred inflation metric assesses prices paid for domestic purchases of goods and services, excluding food and energy. 

Stock List Performance

Strategy YTD YTD vs S&P 500 Inception vs S&P 500
Granny Shots
+17.90%
+5.40%
+87.80%
View
Disclosures (show)

Sign in to read the report!

We have detected you are an active member!

Ray: 7584e7-ae0e4f-6a2286-e059cf-305f08

Want to receive Regular Market Updates to your Inbox?

I am your default error :)

Events

Trending tickers in our research