Our Views

Tom Lee, CFA
AC
Head of Research
FY22 Target: 5100
YE P/E: 20.5x
EPS: 250

The best case scenario for yesterday was “horrible CPI miss and stocks rally”

I was at two finance investor gatherings last night (midtown 5 minutes apart) and there was naturally a lot of discussion about what would be the best “case” outcome for yesterday’s CPI (Sept) report. No surprise, the views ranged from “CPI below expectations and we rally” etc but the most cogent was made by a family office investor:

  • best case is “way hotter CPI print and stocks tank at open then reverse into close”
  • an example as Mark Newton, Head of Technical Strategy, likes to say “markets bottom on bad news”

Well, this is what happened.

  • futures strengthened overnight on UK Truss news
  • Sept CPI reported 8:30 am ET and far stronger than expected
  • futures quickly fall 4%
  • markets open down 2.5% and rally from open

SOFT VS HARD “GAP”: Why is CPI still strong when leading indicators and UIG falling?

We have written about the numerous reasons CPI should be cooling, particularly since so many leading indicators point to lower inflation:

  • take a look at the 50 leading indicators below, roughly half are in outright declines YoY
  • ISMs both manufacturing and services, NFIB, consumer surveys show this and even commodities
  • but the natural question is why there is a differential between these soft indicators and hard data
  • the gap between the “soft” data and “hard” data can arguably be explained by a few things
  • time “gap” as there is a natural lag between when leading indicators versus official data capturing. Shelter and OER (owners equivalent rent) are examples where “new rents” lead these components by months
  • time “lag” as many components might stall in price but YoY declines take longer to form
  • wage factor as ISM prices survey is about prices received, but many CPI components are wage driven
  • collectively, this means there can be lags but the broader picture is cooling inflation

INFLATION DASHBOARD: 27 of 50 items are negative YoY

Various inflation drivers. Sorted by date of “inflation YoY peak”Far worse Sept CPI report, but best case scenario was hot CPI, markets open down and close higher

Source: Fundstrat

 

SOFT VS HARD “GAP”: Used cars remains an example of CPI “GAP” still growing

There is also another lag in the CPI report itself. This is a “gap” between the soft (leading) and hard (actual CPI) report. Eventually, these link up. The process for CPI to compile prices indices. For instance, look at the comparison Manheim vs CPI used cars:

  • CPI used cars YTD is “flat” with no change
  • Manheim shows used car prices down 13% YTD
  • but a similar lag was seen in 2021, where Manheim showed rises
  • but CPI was showing falling car prices
Far worse Sept CPI report, but best case scenario was hot CPI, markets open down and close higher

 

SOFT VS HARD “YoY Takes time”: The “lag” between prices flattening and “YoY showing decline”

We listed some examples of items where the YoY is now becoming favorable. And as the table highlights, the “lag” between the peak in value to when the item becomes “negative YoY” is about 8 months:

  • this is a reminder that CPI index itself will show a similar lag
  • the price level might be slowing (rate of climb) but the YoY impact may not be seen for 8-9 months
Far worse Sept CPI report, but best case scenario was hot CPI, markets open down and close higher
Read the Latest First Word
  • SPX reversal not uncommon after 200 point advance, but stabilizing here important
  • US Dollar looks to be close to peaking out vs Japanese Yen after a tremendous surge
  • WTI Crude looks to be in its final stages of its decline and likely bottoms near $82.50
Read the Latest Daily Technical Strategy
  • The recent economic data has not been friendly for the doves and only further supports the ongoing Fed fighting inflation mission at all costs view.  My indicators are suggesting that I may have to further raise my already hawkish view on where Chairman Powell and Gang may have to go over time.
  • The earnings season is about to get started and move into full swing over the next couple of weeks.  Actual results will likely be OK versus lowered expectations, but the danger is that forward guidance will likely be weak to very weak as the outlook for 2023 is still too high based on research.
  • Rallies are still to be sold not chased by strategic investors.  My key indicators remain quite unfavorable and are suggesting that considerable downside risk remains for the U.S equity markets.
  • Based on this, I continue to advise being careful, cautious, and patient while being on full alert for potential opportunities that may present themselves during my expected challenging period.
Read the Latest Wall Street Whispers
  • Of the six factors we track, momentum, quality and value showed the best performance over the past month. Low volatility was the worst-performing factor.
  • Despite the market sell-off in September, our estimate for the equity risk premium barely changed. As a result, our market valuation methodology continues to see equities as overvalued relative to investment grade fixed income. We continue to expect muted returns and sustained volatility for the equity market in the coming months.
  • Our Reddit-based retail indicator is still in the middle of the range. Corporate bond spreads showing relative strength to equities.
Read the Latest Quantitative Strategy
  • Despite CPI once again coming in hot, crypto continued to perform relatively well. This was quite similar to the price action following the 9.1% headline inflation print in July. Bullish price action on the back of bad news provides further support for constructive near-term price action.
  • Realized and implied volatility in crypto has been declining steadily since the crypto market bottomed in June, leading us to believe this is a great time to buy volatility.
  • Futures open interest for bitcoin continues to climb. While investors should be aware of the leverage embedded in the market, the current makeup of OI appears much healthier than many would expect.
Read the Latest Market Update
  • Congress will return after elections, facing tough decisions on the budget as the just passed CR expires on December 16. Will a Republican victory in either the House or Senate change the dynamics of the debate?
  • Debates can have an impact on close races–below are the debates in some close Senate races
  • The devastation created by hurricane Ian will have some impact on the December CR as Republican members of the Florida and Carolina delegations will be under hometown pressure to approve the legislation, as it likely will contain emergency funds for the victims and hard hit communities.
Read the Latest US Policy

Wall Street Debrief — Weekly Roundup

Key Takeaways

  • Markets had an unexpected rally after a hot CPI number Thursday and then reversed Friday.
  • Energy, Consumer Discretionary and Materials led the losses, all more than 3%. Technology wasn’t far behind, closing down nearly 2.5%.
  • The UK government attempted to assuage the bond market unsuccessfully. Big bank earnings showed mixed results—increasing interest income but cratering deal flow.

Well, that was a truly hectic week in markets. If you don’t like the direction prices are going, just wait a few minutes. The CPI came in hot. It was up 8.2% on a YoY basis and 0.4% for the month, which was above the 0.3% estimate. The report was ugly. Core inflation showed unexpected strength and went up 0.6% against the 0.4% estimate. Futures tanked, and it looked like it was going to be an ugly day. We were right in the middle of our research meeting, and when we emerged, markets had made a serious turn positive and rallied into the close. As Mark Newton said during the meeting, markets have been known to bottom on bad news. There was colossal upside volume. Mr. Newton also mentioned the enormous low to high range was a positive from a technical perspective.

Then on Friday, the S&P 500 opened lower, started to turn a bit higher, and bled down all the way to close at the day's lows. Other things in the morning rattled stocks. However, after the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Survey showed increasing inflation expectations, markets moved to the day's lows into the close. The Fed has gotten a hot jobs number, a hot CPI number, and rising consumer inflation expectations going into its next meeting in the first days of November. Markets are understandably on edge. The 10-yr again closed above 4%, and the Nasdaq dropped the most out of the major indices, losing more than 3%. If you’re unsure why rising interest rates affect Technology stocks the most, see our complimentary FSI Academy Guide on the issue here. Stocks with a larger proportion of their present value backed by future earnings are discounted more heavily when rates rise, and thus their valuations are pressured.

Source: FS Insight

The Fed is such a powerful force in the economy because it controls the rates that govern the friction of economic activity. If you think of the economy as a farm and the Fed controlling the “rain” (liquidity), then stocks with high P/E ratios are like crops that need a lot of water. Your almond crop is just not going to do its best in a drought—even if you’ve got good seeds. The headwinds for the economy are increasing from the Fed’s tightening. You could see it in the bank earnings. Net Interest Income is rising, which is suitable for the banks but is also at the expense of American businesses and consumers. Despite increasing stresses on consumers, they still have credit utilization rates below pre-COVID levels in some cases, so they may be able to limp along longer than usual despite declining economic conditions.

The proverbial drought of liquidity is also affecting deal flow. Morgan Stanley's profit was down 29%, and the rapidly declining deal flow resulted in a 55% decline in investment banking revenue. On the consumer side, mortgage volumes are way down as rates continue to rise. Interestingly, mortgage rates are rising faster than the 10-yr yield. In the runup to March 2020 and the financial crisis, spreads widened because the Fed was loosening, and mortgage rates remained persistently high. Now, the spread is rising because mortgage rates are rising faster than the 10-yr.

UK Prime Minister Liz Truss tried to give a peace offering to the bond vigilantes as she fired her finance minister Kwasi Kwarteng. She also reversed her pledge to reverse Boris Johnson’s corporate tax increase from 19% to 25%. “It’s clear that parts of our mini-budget went further and faster than markets were expecting,” said the imperiled Prime Minister. Gilts rallied going into the announcement but reversed soon after. It seems that bond markets are right.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies estimates that the government will need to save about 60 billion pounds a year to fill the hole caused by the rising interest rates and the tax cuts. To give an idea of the size of this hole, the British government would have to do a universal 15% cut across all government departments to fill about half of it. So, the UK is potentially facing severe austerity to right the pound—the kind some Southern European countries did ten years ago.

The Bank of England’s emergency bond program also ended on Friday. It was on the verge of tightening but was notified that pension plans were on the precipice of outright collapse from the rapid plunge in the pound following the announcement of Truss’s economic program. The so-called “mini-budget” has certainly had more outsized effects than its name would suggest. However, it’s not just about the UK budget because the near-ubiquitous tightening of economic conditions by the world’s central banks is exposing what cracks there could be in the financial system. The UK’s unfortunate saga may not be the last such brushfire that emerges as a world used to free money adjusts to a higher-rate reality.

There’s no way around it. We are in challenging markets, folks. When the going gets tough, the tough get smart. During periods of elevated volatility, it is essential to manage your risk and prevent catastrophic losses. You want to stay in the game, and if you can have the opportunity to set capital aside to buy stocks at discounted levels, even better. This year has seen the lowest percentage of assets work even compared with the weakest periods of recent decades. Investors have been surrounded with nowhere to hide.

Source: Fidelity, @TimmerFidelity

But know the tools available and how to effectively use them during times like these. We can help with that. When you’re surrounded with no place to hide, use whatever tools at your disposal to prevent catastrophic losses. Remember that General Custer, right before his famous last stand at Little Bighorn, decided to not cart along his very cumbersome but very effective Gatling Guns. Had he brought them, it might not have been a last stand at all. Doing the extra work and maintaining your composure during tough markets keeps you alive for the next bull market.

Luckily, we are getting a lot of signs that it’s not as far off as it feels. Pressure has been easing in commodities. There is some progress in labor markets. We dive deep into the leading data indicators and there is a lot of evidence that the main reason for CPI being hot yesterday, shelter, could be a force in the other direction sooner than consensus believes. Sentiment is persistently low and there’s mounting evidence that backward looking inflation indicators aren’t giving a current snapshot. Inflation is collapsing in a lot of areas and it likely will do that soon in a lot of other areas that were most problematic in the recent CPI reading.

Still, the Fed is sticking to its guns and is showing nearly unprecedented rhetorical discipline while hiking at an unprecedented pace. The Fed is in a rhetorical box and likely knows there is progress on inflation but doesn’t want to take their pedal off the gas to maintain credibility. The continually hot CPI reports and jobs numbers may verify their approach, as their biggest fear is that expectations come unanchored, and inflation runs clear out of their control. It’s the highest stakes (financially) game of chicken in the world right now. Meanwhile, Ford, Samsung, and even Big Cap Tech are all sending warning signals, cutting spending and hiring, and essentially battening down the hatches.

It is a very tough market out there, and as your personal Wall Street research team, we’ll be continuing to provide you valuable insights. We aren’t future tellers, and we don’t purport to be. However, we have a capable research team with diverse methodologies and a century of combined experience on Wall Street. We aim to provide you with the same type of guidance that a riverboat captain provides. During tough waters, it’s even more important to have the guidance of those that know the river.

The Sun means that we are going to have wind tomorrow; that floating log means that the river is rising, small thanks to it; that slanting mark on the water refers to a bluff reef which is going to kill somebody's steamboat one of these nights, if it keeps on stretching out like that; those tumbling ‘boils’ show a dissolving bar and a changing channel there; the lines and circles in slick water over yonder are a warning that troublesome place is shoaling up dangerously.” -Mark Twain, Two Ways of Looking at a River

Important Events

US Housing Starts
Tue, Oct 18 7:00 AM ET

Est: 1463K Prev: 1575K

The total number of single family houses that started construction over the covered period. Housing starts are typically viewed as a leading economic indicator.

Fed Beige Book
Wed, Oct 19 2:00 PM ET

The Fed Beige Book is based on survey data from businesses across the geographically and economically diverse twelve districts of the Federal Reserve system.

Initial Jobless Claims
Thu, Oct 20 8:30 AM ET

Est: 230K Prev: 228K

Initial jobless claims measures the number of people who filed for unemployment insurance over the past week.

Stock List Performance

Strategy YTD YTD vs S&P 500 Inception vs S&P 500
Granny Shots
+12.99%
+3.88%
+112.93%
View
Sector Allocation
+11.75%
-4.16%
+0.90%
View
Brian’s Dunks
Performance available here.
Disclosures (show)

Stay up to date with the latest articles and business updates. Subscribe to our newsletter

Articles Read 1/2

🎁 Unlock 1 extra article by joining our Community!

Stay up to date with the latest articles. You’ll even get special recommendations weekly.

Already have an account? Sign In

Want to receive Regular Market Updates to your Inbox?

I am your default error :)